trotsky history of the russian revolution review

Isaac Deutscher, himself a brilliant historian and the biographer of Trotsky, writes, “as in the best … There are certainly some parts that are more difficult than others, and some where clearly Trotsky assumes an understanding of what happened in Russia during 1917 - an expectation of his readers that would have been utterly reasonable for the audience he was writing for, at the time he was writing, but which at times can be a bit confusing for a Westerner reading it almost 100 years later. It is also beautifully written. Write a review. At some point I couldn't bear anymore the amount of lies and blind-eyeing about bolsheviks intentions, actions and methods. OK I really likes this book. Trotsky shows off the scope of his analysis, and sharpness of his politics, all while maliciously mocking his rivals. What he had to say about the whole thing in 1931? Isaac Deutscher, Trotsky's biographer, described The History of the Russian Revolution as Trotsky's, "Crowning work, both in scale and power and as the fullest expression of his ideas on revolution." It is, undoubtedly in my view, well worth the effort that it will take you to get through it. You have to take Trotsky's writings with some amount of skepticism in how he portrays Stalin especially in a bad light, given when this was written and Trotsky's agenda to regain political power after having been forced out of the Bolshevik party. Trotsky & his ilk are to blame? The classic account of the social, economic, and political dynamics of the first socialist revolution as told by one of its central leaders. This famed and, perhaps overly, influential book is, if nothing else, a very good read. However, because of his association with the October revolution and the amazing denigration by Stalin, he became ostracised throughout the world. A phenomenal work of historical and political writing. E.H. Carr's History of the Russian Revolution offers an excellent multi-volume set that tells that story through the 1920's. --Leon Trotsky, from History of the Russian Revolution Regarded by many as among the most powerful works of history ever written, this book offers an unparalleled account of one of the most pivotal and hotly debated events in world history. Trotsky's History of the Russian Revolution is a long, very complex, and extremely detailed treatment of the remarkably eventful period from February to October of 1917. I recommended this book to anyone who enjoys history as much as I do, because it is interesting and astonishing piece of literature and history. Although originally written in Russian and translated into English it was so well presented that I felt that I was being spoken to by the author rather than reading off pages. After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in. This book is essentially a three part dismantling of the Provisional Government, Executive Committee, and all the protagonists of the period between the February and October Revolutions, with special emphases on Kerensky, Miliukov, and of course the bourgeoisie. Jew Review: ‘Trotsky’ on Netflix. One of the brilliant political works of all time and a reflection of Trotsky, the defamed genius. Leon Trotsky's History of the Russian Revolution is partisan history at its best. Customer reviews 4.6 out of 5 stars Prime members enjoy FREE Delivery and exclusive access to music, movies, TV shows, original audio series, and Kindle books. Trotsky was, along with Lenin, a central leader of the 1917 revolution and of the government it established. $30. Wow! As in so many personal accounts of historical events, there is much to be gained from works by those who lived in and had a major part in the history itself. As both a history and an original source, this account of the Revolution gives readers a vital perspective on the interplay of events in Russia from the overthrow of the aristocracy in February to the seizure of power by the working class in October of 1917. And Trotsky's gift for metaphor is second only to the likes of Shakespeare, Homer and Milton. One simply asks that the historian present his or her narrative and analysis and get out of the way. Illustrated. ... Start your review of The History of the Russian Revolution, Vol 2. Transcribed for the World Wide Web by John Gowland (Australia), Alphanos Pangas (Greece) and David Walters (United States), 1997 through 2000, re-proofed 2018 as per eBook Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. Conversely, prominent literary critics such as Edmund Wilson and Irving Howe felt Trotsky's 'History of the Russian Revolution', was a literary masterpiece, and Trotsky, who was extremely critical of everything he wrote (although it is equal to his 'history', in my mind, Trotsky felt his autobiography was one of the worst books he ever wrote), also thought it was his best work. This really shows how the revolution was started through people who cared about a cause, and that materialistic items don't matter if there is a group of people that truly believe in something. After Lenin's death in 1924, he led the international fight to defend the Bolshevik's revolutionary course against the conservative and reactionary bureaucracy headed by Joseph Stalin that came to power later in the Soviet Union. One was Gibbon's Decline and Fall, the other Trotsky's History. The modestly told tale of Trotsky's personal life is beautifully woven with the monumental tale of the crisis of capital, war and the class struggle. Its demerits are firstly a consistent rather weird style, which sure can be accounted for by its age and the fact of translation, but that doesn’t change it, and of course that it is a partial account, which is fine, and actually adds to the notability and interestingness of it, but it also means you just miss crucial information, like as an example, nowhere is it explained who the Social Revolutionaries are, what they want, how they plan to go about it, why the Social Democrats are implacably opposed to them etc. I don't think any other history of the revolution is as detailed, as comprehensive, and as engaging as this. History of the Russian Revolution is a two-volume book by Leon Trotsky on the Russian Revolution of 1917. Trotsky’s admiration of Lenin’s vision and contempt for Stalin’s bureaucratic mind is delicious. Leon Trotsky was a leader of the Russian revolution in 1917 and is the author of My Life, The History of the Russian Revolution, and The Revolution Betrayed. Trotsky's masterpiece and not only the greatest work of history, but a great work of literature. The History of the Russian Revolution, Vol 2 book. He is both ruthless and empathetic. July 1st 2008 The writing itself needs a positive major comment. Given how his life ended that may be a toss up? Some quotes forthcoming comrades. Welcome back. Leon Trotsky awaited the inevitable as he fed his rabbits on the afternoon of August 20, 1940. The book was initially published in Germany in 1930. Eight months later the Bolsheviks stood at the helm. Hell with him and his book. Got 1/3 through and finally surrendered. Leon Trotsky is very unbiased and modest in the book and develops multiple perspectives. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. Additionally, as an even younger person, I even read condensed works of fiction--usually from Readers' Digests' books which Nanny, our paternal grandmother, had around her cottage in Michigan. It gave great insights into the Russian Revolution in great detail. For a more journalistic account John Reed's classic Ten Days That Shook the World is invaluable. It's a tough read, not easily digestible. Russia at the time was at war with Germany as part of an entente or three-country … I just finished reading Volume 3 of Leon Trotsky's History of the Russian Revolution. REVIEW of TROTSKY's HISTORY OF THE RUSSIAN REVOLUTION. Trotsky, the greatest political thinker of the twentieth century, Reviewed in the United States on November 4, 2015. Horribly boring and fixated on minutia vs the big picture which is what I was seeking. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Trotsky’s History of the Russian Revolution on the Centennial of the Revolution. Trotsky’s own supporters saw him as the only true Leninist. This page works best with JavaScript. What a fascinating read from one of the revolution's leaders. Wow! Hell with him and his book. The english language reader’s enjoyment is greatly accentuated by Max Eastman’s spectacular translation. Trotsky also has said that "they renounce violence when it comes to introducing changes in what already exists, but in defense of an existing order they will not. However, if additionally, you want to get a feel for the molecular process of the Russian Revolution in its ebbs and flows down at the base in the masses where the revolution was made Trotsky's is the book for you. Well, the only thing he wanted, was to whiten black dog. Trotsky’s History of the Russian Revolution. The best book I ever read! 445 pp. Leon Trotsky’s History of the Russian Revolution ranks with Capital or the Communist Manifesto as foundational document of revolutionary Marxism. Openly biased and without apology, Trotsky recounts the events before, during and after the Bolsheviks rise. Every bit as good as its reputation suggests. This one was above my pay grade. Trotsky's History of the Russian Revolution is a long, very complex, and extremely detailed treatment of the remarkably eventful period from February to October of 1917. The series stars Konstantin Khabensky in the title role. I know the number of years because my elder brother inscribed each of the three volumes with “To Jeff on his 20th birthday”. Leon Trotsky: The History of the Russian Revolution (1.22 The Soviet Congress and the June Demonstration) ... an unhappy Swiss socialist who had been trying to save the Russian revolution and the German social democracy by means of back-stage negotiations with the Hohenzollern diplomats. Leon Trotsky was a leader of the Russian revolution in 1917 and is the author of My Life, The History of the Russian Revolution, and The Revolution Betrayed. At some point I couldn't bear anymore the amount of lies and blind-eyeing about bolsheviks intentions, actions and methods. Now that I'm in it; I am loving the experience. by Haymarket Books. Trotsky is at parts dense, acerbic, witty, and penetrating. Russia at the time was at war with Germany as part of an entente or three-country coalition that also included Great Britain and France. It is clear that the events of 1917, whatever you think of them, deserve study.”. THE RUSSIAN REVOLUTION A New History By Sean McMeekin Basic Books. Disabling it will result in some disabled or missing features. It's a tough read. He was one of the leaders of the Russian October Revolution, second only to Vladimir Lenin. Reviewed in the United States on January 3, 2013. Whatever Trotsky's faults or your own political persuasion, his own history of the Russian Revolution is an excellently written, engaging and energetic work. Trotsky's book is divided into 3 volumes, The Overthrow of Tsarism, the History of the Russian Revolution and the Triumph of the Soviets. What a mind the man had. Comrade Enaa's page:http://www.youtube.com/user/dwgthedLink to the book:http://marxists.org/archive/trotsky/1930/hrr/index.htm But the writing on the history of Russia and the internal tides within the workers and political parties during the 8 months of revolution are absolutely breathtaking. You will not find another such sharp turn in history especially if you remember that it involves a natio, “During the first two months of 1917 Russia was still a Romanov monarchy. Leon Trotsky was Joseph Stalin’s biggest rival after the death of Vladimir Lenin. Leon Trotsky said "Let us not forget that revolutions are accomplished through people, although they be nameless." About the author (2008) Leon Trotsky was a leader of the Russian revolution in 1917 and is the author of My Life, The History of the Russian Revolution, and The Revolution Betrayed. This is like a 3-and-a-half, tho it is definitely worth reading. Years later I reread the complete Decline, but have yet to do the History. What a fascinating read from one of the revolution's leaders. Ahmed Shawki is the editor of the International Socialist Review. Perhaps, if it were about Trotsky or the Bolsheviks, but I would be wary of using it as a general history of the period. 2013, from the on-line version of The History of the Russian Revolution available at the Trotsky Internet Archive. There are times when it really has you on the edge of your seat - and that, no doubt, is largely because it is written by someone who was actually there. Refresh and try again. Although written by a prime participant, it is not a personal memoir but rather a detailed and objective account that never loses sight of the big picture, focusing on the strategy and tactics of each contending class and political party. Trotsky pays great tribune to Lenin but is modest about the fact that Lenin was in hiding at the time of the revolution and it was he, Trotsky, who engineered the revolution and it was he, Trotsky, who constructed the red army from nothing and defeated the establishment forces thus securing the revolution. I think those old bolsheviks who were imprisoned under stalin. The infamous Jewish leader of the communist revolution. Whatever Trotsky's faults or your own political persuasion, his own history of the Russian Revolution is an excellently written, engaging and energetic work. But at the same time, the personal digs and criticisms he levies towards his political adversaries, particularly Stalin, provide fascinating background to the broader political drama. I needed an entry level entree into this topic and this certainly wasn’t it. In … Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for The History of the Russian Revolution. This is a rare glimpse into the mind of one of history's greatest political thinkers as they navigated the decisive moments of revolution. They should have known it would. The first volume is dedicated to the political history of February Revolution and the second to that of October Revolution, with the intention of explaining the relations between these two events. Reviewed in the United States on July 28, 2020. If you're looking for a light read, Trotsky's History of Russian Revolution is not the way to go by any means. This book paints a vivid background on the Russian revolution and provides amazing detail of the corruption of the Tsarist regime and its insensitivity to the mood of the people. During the revolution, people flipped this statement on its head and did anything for a cause. Let's get this out of the way - yes, Trotsky's history is self-serving, both as a defense of the October Revolution and as a prop for Trotsky's own status as a revolutionary. This really shows how the revolution was started through people who cared about a cause, and that materialistic items don't matter if there is a group of people that truly believe in something. With the outbreak of the Russian Revolution of 1905, Trotsky returned to Russia and was again exiled to Siberia when the revolution collapsed. His understanding of the causes of the proletarian and peasant uprising can come across as a little deterministic, and some of his assertions have been proven wrong by the march of history, but at the end of the day I doubt very many contemporaries understood Old Russia with all its foibles and New Russia with all its contradictions and passions as brilliantly as Trotsky. Start by marking “History of the Russian Revolution” as Want to Read: Error rating book. At times, the magnitude of his intellect is absolutely suffocating, and making sense of his complex and nuanced prose can be very challenging. Trotsky is presented as a firm believer in a world-wide revolution, but that doesn't make him innocent or even good. Trotsky meets that criterion. Reviewed in the United States on January 12, 2007. at Amazon.com. WOW 1917 was quite the year. Great Book and well worth the 937 pages to read all three volumes. It took me a good 6 months to get through it, but I would recommend it! Reviewed in the United States on December 7, 2013, This is one of my favorite book. History of the Russian Revolution is an education on how to think about revolution for those who are working to realize revolution in our lifetimes. He says he wants to save people, and yet he is willing to sacrifice anyone for the revolution. I've started reading this because perspective is very interesting: a man who actually MADE the coup and WON civil war was later rejected by the revolution, expelled and murdered. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. You can still see all customer reviews for the product. Trotsky gives a compelling historical explanation of the failure of Russia to keep pace with the political developments in the West which resulted in a revolution intending to take backward Russia without any experience of western democratic developments to a revolutionary state. Trotsky was one of the great political thinkers of the last century. This is one of the best histories of a single year I’ve yet read. The first volume primarily looks at Russia under Tsarism, the February Revolution, the Provisional Government and the initial formulation of a new strategy upon the arrival of Lenin back to Russia. You have to take Trotsky's writings with some amount of skepticism in how he portrays Stalin especially in a bad light, given when this was written and Trotsky's agenda to regain political power after having been forced out of the Bolshevik party. Top subscription boxes – right to your door, See all details for History of the Russian Revolution, © 1996-2020, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. On the centenary of the Bolshevik Revolution, a lavish, big-budget series on state-run Russian television showcases Leon Trotsky’s life but warns of the chaos that rebellion can bring. Translated by Max Eastman, 1932 Library of Congress Catalog Card Number 8083994 ISBN 0913460834. Here is Trotsky at the height of his elocution. It doesn't hurt that Trotsky is an incredible writer and thinker, and he breathes life into every event in the 8 month period the 1000 page book covers. There was so much more in this work than one usually has access to and explains what, why and how the events happened and the people who affected the happenings.

Judy Hopps Police, Luv Vs The World Wallpaper, Tibouchina Jules - Lasiandra, Suburban Hospital Fax Number, Mashed Potato Pancakes Without Flour, Idea Requires Schools To Do All Of The Following Except,

Read Also

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Solve : *
2 × 8 =